Early Games
The table below provides a chronology of the earliest documented baseball games played by Canadian teams, whether played in Canada or otherwise. It is primarily the fruits of the research of CCBR Director Martin Lacoste, augmented by the contributions and commentary of CCBR Director Bill Humber, Ottawa researcher Steve Rennie, and Tillsonburg researcher Graham Nickerson. Research covers all years through 1870, i.e. before the advent of the organized professional era with the National Association in 1871. Supporting documentation is included via links to the appropriate source in the BOX column; commentary and discussion can be found through similar links in the NOTES column. Discussion covers such issues as the rules under which the game seems to have been played, e.g. the New York rules or the rules of the 11-man “Canadian baseball”.
Please note that this table is a work in progress. Corrections and additions, preferably accompanied by underlying source documentation, are welcomed, especially for games played outside Ontario (Canada West).
Abbreviations:
BC Buffalo Courier
BCOM Buffalo Commercial
BDC Buffalo Daily Courier
BME Buffalo Morning Express
BrC British Columbian
BWE Brantford Weekly Expositor
CG Canadian Gleaner
DFP Detroit Free Press
GA Guelph Advertiser
GEM Guelph Evening Mercury
GH Guelph Herald
GM Guelph Mercury
GWM Guelph Weekly Mercury
G&M Toronto Globe
HS Hamilton Spectator
HT Hamilton Times
HWS Hamilton Weekly Spectator
HWT Hamilton Weekly Times
IC Ingersoll Chronicle
KBW Kingston Weekly British Whig
KWS Kingston Whig Standard
LFP London Free Press
MA Mitchell Advocate and County of Perth General Advertiser
MES Montreal Evening Star
MG Montreal Gazette
MH Montreal Herald and Daily Commercial Gazette
NYC New York Clipper
NYSM New York Sunday Mercury
ODC Ottawa Daily Citizen
ODJ Ogdensburg Daily Journal
OIS Orleans Independent Standard
OT Ottawa Times
PDND Port Dover New Dominion
REE Rochester Evening Express
SCEJ St. Catharines Evening Journal
SDC Syracuse Daily Courier
SDS Syracuse Daily Standard
STWD St. Thomas Weekly Dispatch
TO Tillsonburg Observer
VC Weekly British Colonist and Victoria Chronicle
VDC Victoria Daily Columnist
VET Victoria Evening Telegraph
WSOT Wilkes’ Spirit of the Times
| YR | DATE | WINNER | LOSER | SCORE | LOC/H | NOTES | BOX |
| 1856 | Sep 15 | London | Delaware | 34-33 | London | 2 innings. Discussion | NYC |
| 1858 | Jul 03 | Buffalo | Base Ball Club of Hamilton at Buffalo Base Ball Club. First mention of cross-border play between Canadians and Americans. BCOM | ||||
| 1858 | Aug 13 | West (Hamilton) | East (Hamilton) | 115-53 | Hamilton | Discussion | HS |
| 1858 | Aug 18 | Hamilton Young Canadians | Hamilton Burlingtons | Hamilton | Previewed HS. | ||
| 1859 | May 24 | Toronto Young Canadians | Hamilton Young Americans | 68-41 | Hamilton | 1st game(?) under NY rules; nothing in HT (though a cricket score and quoits score are recorded). Discussion | NYC, HT |
| 1859 | May 24 | Toronto cigar makers | Hamilton cigar makers | +27 pins | Hamilton | Alternate reference to same 1st game under NY rules above: HS59May28. 1st team in Toronto for which we have a reference. Discussion. | |
| 1859 | Aug 15 | Burlington | Young Canadian | +12 | Hamilton | HS59Aug16 | |
| 1860 | Jul 04 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Olympic | ? | From NYSM (RIM) | ||
| 1860 | Jul 18 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Rough and Readys | 83-59 | Ingersoll | ‘Canadian’ rules. IC. Discussion | NYC |
| 1860 | Jul 25 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Rough and Readys | 100-58 | Woodstock | IC | NYC |
| 1860 | Aug 11 | Prescott Greenvilles | Prescott Victorias | 32-11 | Prescott | NYC | |
| 1860 | Aug 17 | Buffalo Queen City | Hamilton Burlingtons | 30-25 | Clifton (now Niagara Falls, Ont.) | First match between U.S. and Canada teams. HS60Aug18. Discussion | BME |
| 1860 | Aug 29 | Buffalo Niagaras | Hamilton Young Canadians | 87-13 | Hamilton | BDC | |
| 1860 | Sep 09 | Prescott Greenvilles | Ogdensburg Empires | 23-16 | Prescott | 3 innings | NYC |
| 1860 | Sep 28 | Buffalo Niagaras | Hamilton Young Canadians | 46-15 | Buffalo | Says Toronto, but must be Hamilton team. HS60Oct02. | BDC |
| 1860 | Oct 02 | Prescott Greenvilles | Spencerville Unions | 101-21 | Prescott | NYC | |
| 1861 | Guelph | Flamborough | 27-27 | First game played by Guelph Maple Leafs. Discussion | |||
| 1861 | Jun 03 | Woodstock Young Canadian | Woodstock picked nine | 10-7 | Woodstock | First match played there under NY rules. | NYC |
| 1861 | Jun 14 | Burlington – Bachelors | Burlington – Benedicts | 77-43 | Burlington | HT, HS | |
| 1861 | Jun 28 | Burlington – Bachelors | Burlington – Benedicts | 63-54 | Burlington | HT, HS | |
| 1861 | Jul 12 | Burlington | Barton | 56-45 | Burlington | HT, HS | |
| 1861 | Jul 20 | Greenville – Waugh’s side | Greenville – Langhorn’s side | 27-11 | Prescott | NYC | |
| 1861 | Jul 30 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Hamilton Burlingtons | 33-27 | Hamilton | NYC, HT, HS | |
| 1861 | Aug 06 | Bowmanville Live Oaks | Port Hope Mechanics | 88-66 | Port Hope | NYC | |
| 1861 | Aug 09 | Burlington | Barton | 42-24 | Barton | HT, HS | |
| 1861 | Aug 20 | Burlington | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 42-40 | 7 innings (darkness) | HT, HS | |
| 1861 | Aug 23 | Hamilton Burlingtons | Detroit | 55-52 | Detroit | KWS 61Aug30. 1st Canadian victory in international match? | HS, DFP |
| 1861 | Sep 03 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 24-22 | Hamilton | 2:45 | NYC, HT |
| 1862 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Guelph | ‘more than balanced the score’ | ||||
| 1862 | Apr 28 | Woodstock Y.C. (McWhinnie’s side) | Woodstock Y.C. (Wilson’s side) | 12-11 | Woodstock | NYC | |
| 1862 | May 24 | New Westminster | Queen’s birthday celebrations. BrC62May24. | ||||
| 1862 | Jun 14 | West Flamboro | Ancaster Victorias | 77-26 | Ancaster | HS62Jun17. | |
| 1862 | Jun 20 | Burlington | Barton | 28-27 | HT, HS | ||
| 1862 | Jun 21 | Barton | Ancaster Victorias | 34-30 | HS62Jun24. | ||
| 1862 | Jul 08 | Barton | West Flamboro | 83-26 | West Flamboro | HT, HS | |
| 1862 | Jul 11 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Hamilton Burlingtons | 9-0 | Hamilton | Forfeit (Burlington did not appear). HS62Jul12. | HT |
| 1862 | Aug 01 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Barton | 57-28 | Barton | HT, HS | |
| 1862 | Aug 10 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 41-14 | Woodstock | HT | |
| 1862 | Aug 23 | West Flamboro | Hamilton Union | 30-10 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1862 | Sep 05 | Barton | West Flamboro | 36-17 | HT, HS | ||
| 1862 | Sep 18 | West Flamboro | Hamilton Union | 28-11 | West Flamboro | HT, HS | |
| 1862 | Sep 30 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Barton | ? | Burlington | Game announced, but possibly not played. See HT62Sep29, HS62Sep29. | |
| 1863 | Mar 14 | Victoria | First match of the season. VDC63Mar16. | ||||
| 1863 | Mar 24 | H(x)cbuck? | Fashion Club of Victoria | 39-33 | Victoria | VDC | |
| 1863 | Mar 30 | Fashion Club of Victoria | Victoria Cricketers | 42-28 | Victoria | VDC | |
| 1863 | Jul 03 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Barton | 28-24 | HS63Jul04. | HT | |
| 1863 | Jul 14 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Detroit – Brother Jonathan Club | 29-6 | Detroit | DFP | |
| 1863 | Jul 31 | Hamilton Maple Leafs (Non-Volunteers) | Hamilton Maple Leafs (Volunteers) | 27-21 | Hamilton | HT, HS | |
| 1863 | Aug 17 | Saint-Jean volunteer soldiers | Battalion of Montreal Artillery | Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu | MH 63Aug20. | ||
| 1863 | Aug 25 | Hamilton Maple Leafs (Single) | Hamilton Maple Leafs (Married) | 54-36 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1863 | Sep 01 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 41-25 | Hamilton | Home and home match #1. | HT, HS |
| 1863 | Sep 15 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 26-12 | Woodstock | Home and home match #2. | HT, HS |
| 1863 | Oct 01 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Barton | 28-27 | Hamilton | HT, HS | |
| 1864 | Jun 29 | Barton | Hamilton Maple Leaf | 39-36 | Hamilton | HT, HWT | |
| 1864 | Jul 04 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Victorias | +3 | Ingersoll | IC | |
| 1864 | Jul 28 | Hamilton Maple Leaf | Barton | 31-18 | HT | ||
| 1864 | Jul 29 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 15-13 | Hamilton | Mentioned also in GM 27Jun20, which gives year as 1863. | GM, HWT |
| 1864 | Aug 15 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 30-2 | Woodstock | Silver Ball game? G&M 64Aug24. | NYC, HT, HWT |
| 1864 | Aug 22 | Flamboro | Guelph | 13-10 | Guelph | GM, HT | |
| 1864 | Aug 23 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Victorias | 37-12 | Woodstock | NYC | |
| 1864 | Sep 15 | Barton | Flamboro | 39-25 | Barton | HT, HWT | |
| 1864 | Sep 19 | Flamboro | Guelph Maple Leafs | 22-12 | Guelph | GM, HT, HWT | |
| 1864 | Sep 22 | Brooklyn Atlantics | Woodstock Young Canadians | 75-11 | Rochester | HS64Sep23. IC has score 74-11, with winner from Atlanta, NY. | NYC, REE |
| 1864 | Sep 24 | Toronto Torontos | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 148-139 | Toronto | From WSOT (10/8). Discussion | |
| 1864 | Sep 30 | Western (Ingersoll) | Eastern (Flamboro) | 19-15 | Hamilton | ~All-Star game. Western composed of players from Ingersoll, Woodstock, Guelph; Eastern from Flamboro, Barton, Hamilton Maple Leafs. HS64Oct01. | HT, HWT, IC |
| 1865 | May 05 | Hamilton Maple Leafs (Shuttleworth Nine) | Hamilton Maple Leafs (Cooper nine) | 34-21 | Hamilton | 5 innings | HT |
| 1865 | May 24 | Hamilton Maple Leafs (Knight nine) | Hamilton Maple Leafs (Shuttleworth nine) | 30-27 | Hamilton | Queen’s Birthday | HT |
| 1865 | Jun 15 | Guelph | Niagara City Club | 44-3 | Niagara | 5 innings | GM |
| 1865 | Jun 27 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | West Flamboro | 34-11 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1865 | Jun 29 | Guelph Maple Leafs (9 single) | Guelph Maple Leafs (6 married) | 50-25 | Guelph | GM | |
| 1865 | Jun 30 | West Flamboro | Barton | 35-17 | HT | ||
| 1865 | Jul 07 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Dundas Independents | 25-23 | Dundas | HS | |
| 1865 | Jul 14 | Dundas Independents | Hamilton Maple Leafs (2nd nine) | 25-22 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1865 | Jul 17 | Hamilton | Guelph | 25-15 | Guelph | GWM and HT list different batting orders. | GWM, HT |
| 1865 | Jul 24 | Guelph (1st nine) | Victoria | +7 | Guelph | GM | |
| 1865 | Jul 24 | Hamilton (2nd nine) | Guelph (2nd nine) | 45-12 | Hamilton | GM | HS |
| 1865 | Jul 26 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Victorias | 69-40 | Woodstock | For the championship and the Silver Ball | IC |
| 1865 | Jul 27 | Hamilton Maple Leafs (2nd nine) | Hamilton Stars (1st nine) | 36-18 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1865 | Aug 01 | Dundas | Flamboro | +8 | HS | ||
| 1865 | Aug 02 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Niagara | 30-17 | Niagara | HT | |
| 1865 | Aug 02 | Hamilton Star (1st nine) | Hamilton Defiance (1st nine) | 38-14 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1865 | Aug 03 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Niagara City | 102-37 | Niagara City | Mentioned HT 65Aug05. | NYC |
| 1865 | Aug 07 | Guelph (3rd nine) | Victoria | 33-16 | Guelph | GM | |
| 1865 | Aug 15 | Woodstock | Newcastle Beavers | 80-28 | Woodstock | HT, GM | IC |
| 1865 | Aug 16 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Newcastle Beavers | 35-20 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1865 | Aug 17 | West Flamboro | Guelph Maple Leafs | 21-19 | West Flamboro | GM | |
| 1865 | Aug 18 | Woodstock | Dundas Mechanics | +2 | Dundas | HS | |
| 1865 | Aug 25 | West Flamboro | Barton | 44-18 | Barton | HS | |
| 1865 | Aug 30 | Hamilton Maple Leaf | Ingersoll Victoria | 26-24 | Hamilton | Mentioned HT 65Aug25. | HT, IC |
| 1865 | Sep 01 | Flamboro | Guelph Maple Leafs | 17-14 | Guelph | GM. HT describes meeting of Maple Leaf B.B.C. | HT |
| 1865 | Sep 05 | Ingersoll Victorias (Hearn’s nine) | Ingersoll Victorias (Jarvis’s nine) | 55-30 | Ingersoll | IC | |
| 1865 | Sep 07 | Montreal Volunteer Cavalry officers | Montreal Volunteer Cavalry troopers | Rivieres des Prairies | No. 2 Troop of Montreal Volunteer Cavalry. Rivieres des Prairies is called Back River in English. MH 65Sep07. | ||
| 1865 | Sep 08 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Dundas | Hamilton | Mentioned HT 65Aug30. Rained out? | ||
| 1865 | Sep 11 | Hamilton Stars (1st nine) | Hamilton Maple Leafs (2nd nine) | 31-16 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1865 | Sep 13 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Lockport Niagara | (9-0) | Hamilton | Mentioned HT 65Aug30. Not played (HS 65Sep11). | |
| 1865 | Sep 15 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Dundas Mechanics | 36-28 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1865 | Sep 18 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Hamilton Cricketers | 58-7 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1865 | Sep 20 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Woodstock Young Canadians | (9-0) | London | Forfeit; dispute over type of ball. See HT 65Sep20. | |
| 1865 | Oct 10 | Barton & West Flamboro | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 36-22 | Hamilton | Announcement of Silver Cup match. HT | HS |
| 1865 | Oct 18 | Barton & Flamboro | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 24-17 | Hamilton | Silver Cup match | HT, HWT |
| 1865 | Oct 18 | Ingersoll Victorias | Woodstock Young Canadians | ? | Ingersoll | IC. Was game played? | |
| 1866 | May 17 | Hamilton Maple Leafs nine | Hamilton Maple Leafs nine | 35-22 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1866 | Jun 06 | Hamilton Stars (1st nine) | Dundas Live Oaks (1st nine) | +7 | Dundas | HS | |
| 1866 | Jun 06 | Dundas Independents (1st nine) | Hamilton Stars (1st nine) | 36-20 | Dundas | HS | |
| 1866 | Jul 04 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Flamboro Live Oaks | 32-12 | Flamboro | See GM 66Jul05. | |
| 1866 | Jul 04 | Flamboro (2nd nine) | Guelph (2nd nine) | +21 | Flamboro | See GM 66Jul05. | |
| 1866 | Jul 10 | Ingersoll Victoria Wood and Iron Men | Ingersoll Victoria Leather Men | 71-50 | Ingersoll | IC | |
| 1866 | Jul 24 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Victoria | 65-53 | Ingersoll | IC | |
| 1866 | Jul 25 | Hamilton Eagles | Hamilton Independent | 90-39 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1866 | Jul 30 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Dundas Mechanics | 98-50 | Woodstock | HS, HT, IC. Hamilton papers give 98-48 score. | NYC |
| 1866 | Jul 30 | Woodstock | Dundas | 98-48 | Woodstock | See HT 66Jul31. Championship of Western Canada. | |
| 1866 | Aug 07 | Hamilton Young Canadians | Dundas Independents | 45-10 | Hamilton | See HT 66Aug08. | HS |
| 1866 | Aug 08 | Newcastle | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 75-44 | Newcastle | See HT 66Aug09. | |
| 1866 | Aug 14 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Ingersoll Victorias | 45-17 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1866 | Aug 15 | Guelph Maple Leafs (Benedicts) | Guelph Maple Leafs (Bachelors) | HS | |||
| 1866 | Aug 18 | Hamilton Eagles (1st nine) | Hamilton Independents (2nd nine) | 51-8 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1866 | Sep 01 | Woodstock Grammar School | Ingersoll Grammar School | Woodstock | IC 66Sep07. | ||
| 1866 | Sep 04 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Dundas Independent | +9 | Woodstock | IC 66Sep07. | |
| 1866 | Sep 10 | Ingersoll Grammar School | Woodstock Actives | 31-27 | Ingersoll | IC | |
| 1866 | Sep 28 | East (Hamilton) | West (Ingersoll) | 25-21 | Hamilton | G&M, HT | |
| 1866 | Oct 03 | Woodstock | Dundas | +11 | Woodstock | Silver Ball game. See HT 66Oct04. | |
| 1866 | Oct 05 | Union | Guelph Maple Leafs | 56-28 | Guelph | See GM 66Oct11. | |
| 1866 | Oct 07 | Victoria Olympics First Nine | Victoria Olympics Second Nine | 34-24 | Victoria | VET. Appears to be earliest recorded game for Olympics. Earliest game listed on Protoball site is 20Oct1866 against cricket club. | |
| 1866 | Oct 10 | Woodstock | West Flamboro | +15 | Woodstock | Silver Ball Championship of Western Canada. See HT 66Oct11. | |
| 1866 | Oct 13 | Victoria | Olympic BBC | 23-17 | Victoria | VC 66Oct16. | |
| 1866 | Nov 10 | Victoria | Olympic BBC | +30 | Victoria | VC 66Nov13. | |
| 1866 | Nov 24 | Olympic BBC | City BBC | Victoria | VC 66Nov27. | ||
| 1867 | Jun 14 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Flamboro Live Oak | 58-40 | Guelph | See GH 67Jun18. | |
| 1867 | Jun 21 | Ingersoll “Always Ready” | Woodstock Atlantics | 91-31 | Woodstock | IC | |
| 1867 | Jul 12 | Ingersoll Victorias | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 109-53 | Ingersoll | Mentioned HT 67Jul13 | IC |
| 1867 | Jul 24 | Hamilton Independent | Hamilton Eagles | 52-47 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1867 | Jul 24 | Ingersoll “Always Ready” | Woodstock Atlantics | 52-43 | Ingersoll | IC | |
| 1867 | Jul 26 | Dundas Independents (1st nine) | Guelph Unions (1st nine) | +27 | Dundas | See GM 67Jul23 and 27 | |
| 1867 | Jul 26 | Dundas Independents (2nd nine) | Guelph Unions (2nd nine) | +16 | See GM 67Jul23 and 27 | ||
| 1867 | Aug 07 | Hamilton Eagles | Hamilton Independents | 47-33 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1867 | Aug 08 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 62-17 | Hamilton | Called draw as Guelph caught last train. | GM, HS |
| 1867 | Aug 12 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Hamilton Stars | 35-31 | Hamilton | HT, HS | |
| 1867 | Aug 12 | Hamilton Independent (2nd nine) | Hamilton Stars (2nd nine) | 129-73 | Hamilton | 8 innings; darkness. See HT 67Aug13. | |
| 1867 | Aug 14 | Hamilton Independent (2nd nine) | Hamilton Stars (2nd nine) | 118-49 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1867 | Aug 15 | Hamilton Maple Leaf | Port Huron Welkin | 19-10 | Detroit | Tournament (67Aug31 NYC); 3 innings. Postponement from previous day (DFP). | HS, DFP |
| 1867 | Aug 15 | Allegheny Alleghenies | Woodstock Young Canadians | 55-35 | Detroit | Tournament. Mentioned in HS 67Aug16. See NYC 67Aug31. | DFP |
| 1867 | Aug 15 | Ingersoll Victorias | Ann Arbor juniors | 40-25 | Detroit | Tournament. Mentioned in HS 67Aug16. | DFP |
| 1867 | Aug 15 | Hamilton Stars | Hamilton Eagles | 77-56 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1867 | Aug 16 | Jackson Unknowns | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 55-38 | Detroit | Tournament | DFP |
| 1867 | Aug 17 | Ingersoll Victorias | Wayne Unions | 40-18 | Detroit | Tournament | DFP |
| 1867 | Aug 19 | Ingersoll Victorias | St. John’s Monitors | 41-14 | Detroit | Tournament. See NYC 67Aug31. | DFP |
| 1867 | Aug 20 | Ingersoll Victorias | Detroit Alerts | 63-19 | Detroit | Tournament. Hamilton Maple Leaf finish 3rd in 1st Class, Ingersoll Victoria 1st in 3rd Class (DFP) | DFP |
| 1867 | Aug 23 | London Forest City “nine” | London Forest City “fourteen” | +60 | London | See LFP 67Aug24. | |
| 1867 | Aug 26 | Guelph Unions (2nd nine) | Dundas Independents (2nd nine) | 119-57 | Guelph | 7 innings. See GM 67Aug27. | |
| 1867 | Aug 29 | Hamilton Golden Leafs | Hamilton Beavers | 52-47 | Hamilton | Postponed after 7 innings; rain. HS | |
| 1867 | Aug 30 | Ogdensburg | Ottawa | 141-20 | Ogdensburg | ODJ 67Aug30. Discussion | |
| 1867 | Aug 30 | Dundas Mechanics | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 57-48 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1867 | Aug 31 | Hamilton Mechanics | Hamilton Ontarios | +18 | Hamilton | 6 innings. HS | |
| 1867 | Sep 02 | Hamilton Stars (2nd nine) | Hamilton Independent (2nd nine) | 62-58 | Hamilton? | HS | |
| 1867 | Sep 06 | London Forest City | London BBC | 59-37 | London | LFP | |
| 1867 | Sep 11? | Hamilton Ontarios | Hamilton Mechanics | 64-46 | Hamilton | 6 innings; rain. | HS |
| 1867 | Sep 14 | Aberfoyle | Guelph Grammar School Club | 71-59 | Aberfoyle | GM | |
| 1867 | Sep 16 | London Forest City | London BBC | 56-41 | London | Weather postponement from Sep13. | LFP |
| 1867 | Sep 17 | Hamilton Actives | Hamilton Star | +7 | Hamilton | Shuttleworth umpire. HS | |
| 1867 | Sep 18 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Dundas Mechanics’ Club | 64-24 | Guelph | GM | |
| 1867 | Sep 18 | Dundas Independents | Woodstock Young Canadians | Dundas | For championship bat. See HT 67Sep20. | ||
| 1867 | Sep 18 | Embro Ontario | Beachville Royals | 49-45 | Beachville | IC 67Sep19. | |
| 1867 | Sep 21 | Victoria BBC “Pretty Nine” | Victoria BBC “Ugly Beauties” | +21 | Victoria | Preview VC 67Sep24, Recap VC 67Sep24. | |
| 1867 | Sep 23 | Guelph Union | Guelph Maple Leafs (2nd nine) | +67 | Guelph | See GM 67Sep24. | |
| 1867 | Sep 28 | Hamilton Ontarios | Hamilton Mechanics | 74-45 | Hamilton | 6 innings. | HS |
| 1867 | Oct 03 | East Flamboro Oak Leaf | Hamilton Maple Leaf | 51-49 | East Flamboro | HS | |
| 1867 | Oct 19 | Hamilton Maple Leaf | Upper Canada College | 45-34 | Hamilton | 7 innings. | HS, G&M |
| 1867 | Oct 24 | Ingersoll Victorias | London Forest City | 77-55 | Ingersoll | IC | |
| 1867 | Oct 25 | Fonthill Union | St. Catharines Frontier | 94-17 | Fonthill | SCEJ | |
| 1867 | Oct 29 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Detroit | 39-37 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1867 | Nov 07 | Hamilton Stars | Paris Dominions | 46-16 | Paris | 7 innings. Stars list only 8 players. | HS |
| 1868 | Apr 09 | Ingersoll Victorias (Hearn’s nine) | Ingersoll Victorias (Taylor’s nine) | 35-32 | Ingersoll | IC | |
| 1868 | May 23 | Guelph Union | Aberfoyle | 52-50 | Guelph | GM | |
| 1868 | May 23 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Dundas Independents | 54-8 | Guelph | GM | |
| 1868 | May 24 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Victorias | 38-27 | Woodstock | IC | |
| 1868 | May 25 | Vagabonds | London Forest Citys | 56-41 | London | LFP | |
| 1868 | May 25 | St. Catharines Frontier | Drummondville Loyal Oaks | 51-40 | Drummondville | SCEJ | |
| 1868 | May 29 | Black Rock Frontier | Fort Erie International | 45-14 | Fort Erie | BC | |
| 1868 | Jun 04 | Hamilton Stars | Hamilton Actives | 29-13 | Hamilton | From NYC 68Nov21. Also HS. | |
| 1868 | Jun 09 | Black Rock Frontier | St. Catharines Frontier | 49-23 | Niagara Falls | Tournament. Mentioned HS 68Jun12. | BC, SCEJ |
| 1868 | Jun 10 | Black Rock Frontier | Hamilton Stars | 25-13 | Niagara Falls | Tournament | BC, BME, HT |
| 1868 | Jun 11 | Buffalo Perews | Hamilton Stars | 30-21 | Niagara Falls | Tournament | BC, BME |
| 1868 | Jun 13 | Guelph Union | Galt Grand River Club | 126-26 | Galt | Mentioned GH 68Jul21, GM 68Jun15. | |
| 1868 | Jun 15 | Brooklyn Atlantics | Woodstock Young Canadians | 30-17 | Niagara Falls | Tournament; 5 innings. Announced in SCEJ, BC, BME 68Jun15. | BC, IC, NYC, GM, HT |
| 1868 | Rockford Forest City | Hamilton Excelsiors | ? | Rockford, Ill. | HS | ||
| 1868 | Jun 19 | Philadelphia Athletics | Hamilton Excelsiors | 33-13 | Hamilton? | HS | |
| 1868 | Jun 20 | Brooklyn Atlantics | Hamilton Excelsiors | 49-17 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1868 | Jun 26 | Hamilton Stars | Hamilton Maple Leaf | 49-39 | From NYC 68Nov21. HS has score 50-39. | HT, HS | |
| 1868 | Jun 27 | Huntingdon Crescent | Durham Rough and Ready | 42-22 | Huntingdon | 12 men a side. CG 68Jun26, CG 68Jun27. | |
| 1868 | Jul 01 | Hamilton Stars | Hamilton Ontario | 64-40 | From NYC 68Nov21. HT has score +21. | ||
| 1868 | Jul 01 | Ogdensburg | Ottawa | +8 | Ottawa | ODJ 68Jul01. | |
| 1868 | Jul 01 | Fort Erie International Club | Black Rock Frontier Club | Fort Erie | KBW 68Jul09, G&M. International match; Black Rock is now a suburb of Buffalo. | ||
| 1868 | Jul 01 | Ingersoll Victoria | London Tecumseh | 53-45 | London | IC | |
| 1868 | Jul 07 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Guelph Maple Leafs | +2 | Woodstock | Silver Ball. See HT 68Jul09, GH 68Jul14. | |
| 1868 | Jul 14 | Hamilton Maple Leafs (2nd nine) | Hamilton Actives (2nd nine) | 56-38 | Hamilton | HT | |
| 1868 | Jul 16 | Guelph Union | Galt Grand River Club | 71-43 | Guelph | GH | |
| 1868 | Jul 16 | Ingersoll Always Ready | Woodstock Atlantics | 64-42 | Ingersoll | IC | IC |
| 1868 | Jul 17 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Hamilton Stars | 67-34 | Hamilton | HT, HS | |
| 1868 | Jul 17 | London Tecumsehs (2nd nine) | Strathroy Excelsiors | 58-16 | Strathroy | See LFP 68Jul18. | |
| 1868 | Jul 20 | Dundas Independents | Hamilton Stars | 68-43 | Hamilton | HS gives score as +27. | |
| 1868 | Jul 23 | Ingersoll Victorias | London Tecumsehs | 54-27 | Ingersoll | IC has score 56-27. | LFP, IC |
| 1868 | Jul 29 | Hamilton Excelsiors | Hamilton Fearless | 85-53 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1868 | Jul 29 | Woodstock Young Canadians | London Tecumsehs | 89-46 | Woodstock | 5 hours. | LFP |
| 1868 | Jul 31 | Victoria BBC | USS Pensacola | 71-46 | Victoria | 6 1/2 innings. | VC |
| 1868 | Aug 04 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Guelph Maple Leafs | 36-28 | Woodstock | Silver Ball. Shuttleworth umpire. | GH, GM |
| 1868 | Aug 04 | London Tecumsehs (1st nine) | London Tecumsehs (2nd nine) | 18-15 | London | 5 innings (darkness). See LFP 68Aug05, LFP 68Aug06. | |
| 1868 | Aug 04 | Dunville Live Oak | Erie of Dover | Port Dover | Previewed PDND 68Jul31. | ||
| 1868 | Aug 06 | London Tecumsehs | St. Thomas Eries | 67-53 | St. Thomas | See LFP 68Aug07. | |
| 1868 | Aug 06 | Port Dover Eries | Dunville Live Oaks | 78-21 | Port Dover | PDND | |
| 1868 | Aug 06 | Hamilton Golden Leaf | Hamilton Defiance | 75-47 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1868 | Aug 10 | Hamilton Actives | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 60-58 | Hamilton | See also HT 68Aug11. | HS |
| 1868 | Aug 10 | Hamilton Stars | Hamilton Golden Leafs | 63-27 | Hamilton | See HT 68Aug11. | |
| 1868 | Aug 10 | Beaver BBC Canadians | Beaver BBC Old Country | 97-44 | Hamilton | See HT 68Aug11. | |
| 1868 | Aug 10 | Defiance | Oak Leaf | 83-62 | Hamilton | See HT 68Aug11. | |
| 1868 | Aug 11 | Ingersoll Victorias | Woodstock Young Canadians | Woodstock | For Silver Ball and championship. Postponed rain (IC 68Aug20). See HT 68Aug11. | ||
| 1868 | Aug 11 | Ingersoll Victorias | Strathroy Excelsiors | 82-24 | Strathroy | See IC 68Aug20. Tour of Victorias. | |
| 1868 | Aug 12 | London Tecumsehs | Ingersoll Victorias | 26-25 | London | Mentioned HT 68Aug13, IC 68Aug13, IC 68Aug20, G&M. Fan behaviour commentary IC 68Aug13. Tour of Victorias. 2:30. | |
| 1868 | Aug 12 | Drummondville Cataracts | St. Catharines Young Mechanics | 93-26 | Drummondville | SCEJ | |
| 1868 | Aug 13 | Ingersoll Victorias | St. Thomas Eries | 50-28 | St. Thomas | See IC 68Aug20. Tour of Victorias. | |
| 1868 | Aug 14 | Guelph Union | Aberfoyle | 54-38 | Aberfoyle | GH, GM | |
| 1868 | Aug 18 | Ingersoll Victorias | Woodstock Young Canadians | 49-23 | Woodstock | For Silver Ball and championship. 6 innings. See IC 68Aug20, GM 68Aug22. | |
| 1868 | Aug 19 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Victorias | 42-34 | Ingersoll | For Silver Ball and championship. 6 innings. See IC 68Aug20, GM 68Aug22, G&M. | |
| 1868 | Aug 21 | Hamilton Actives | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 58-48 | Hamilton | HT, HS | |
| 1868 | Aug 21 | Ogdensburg | New Dominion (Ottawa) | 53-19 | Ogdensburg | ODJ68Aug22 | |
| 1868 | Aug 22 | Guelph Maple Leafs (2nd nine) | Acton Hunkidoras | 113-13 | Acton | GM | |
| 1868 | Aug 22 | Galt Grand River Club (2nd nine) | Aberfoyle (2nd nine) | 76-62 | GM | ||
| 1868 | Aug 22 | Aberfoyle | Galt Grand River Club | 73-43 | Galt | GM | |
| 1868 | Aug 22 | St. Davids Maple Leaf (2nd nine) | Drummondville Cataract (2nd nine) | 45-24 | St. Davids | 5 innings. | SCEJ |
| 1868 | Aug 25 | Hamilton Stars | Buffalo Frank Perews | 54-34 | Hamilton | From NYC 68Nov21. | HT, HS |
| 1868 | Aug 26 | St. Catharines Young Mechanics | St. Catharines Frontier | 43-34 | St. Catharines | SCEJ | |
| 1868 | Aug 26 | Drummondville Cataracts | Niagara New Dominion | 43-15 | Niagara | SCEJ | |
| 1868 | Aug 28 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Hamilton Actives | 90-36 | Hamilton | HT, HS | |
| 1868 | Sep 01 | Ingersoll Victorias | Woodstock Young Canadians | 34-28 | Woodstock | 10 innings. For Silver Ball and championship of Canada. See GH 68Sep15, GM 68Sep04. | IC |
| 1868 | Sep 04 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | Ontario | 101-23 | Hamilton | HT, HS | |
| 1868 | Sep 04 | Ingersoll Victorias | St. Thomas Eries | Ingersoll | See IC 68Sep10. | ||
| 1868 | Sep 07 | Aberfoyle | Guelph Maple Leafs | 41-29 | Guelph | GM | |
| 1868 | Sep 07 | Ingersoll Victorias | Tilsonburg | 109-35 | Tilsonburg | See IC 68Sep10. | |
| 1868 | Sep 09 | Hamilton Golden Leaf | West Flamboro Live Oaks | 54-14 | West Flamboro | HS | |
| 1868 | Sep 09 | St. Catharines Frontier | St. Catharines Young Mechanics | 39-36 | St. Catharines | SCEJ | |
| 1868 | Sep 10 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Victorias | 43-30 | Woodstock | See GH 68Sep15. Mentioned IC 68Sep10. | IC |
| 1868 | Sep 11 | London Tecumsehs | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 69-15 | London | HT | |
| 1868 | Sep 12 | Drummondville Cataracts | Fonthill Fonthills | 28-25 | Niagara Falls | SCEJ | |
| 1868 | Sep 16 | Burlington | Union | 53-21 | HS | ||
| 1868 | Sep 19 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Elora | 65-16 | Elora | 8 innings. | GM |
| 1868 | Sep 21 | Woodstock Atlantics | Ingersoll Always Ready Club | 34-24 | Mentioned in GM 68Sep28. | ||
| 1868 | Sep 22 | Buffalo Frank Perews | Hamilton Stars | 21-15 | Buffalo | 6 innings; rain. Mentioned in HS 68Sep19, NYC 68Nov21. | HT, BC, BME |
| 1868 | Sep 22 | Dundas Independents | London Tecumsehs | 57-26 | Dundas | See HS 68Sep23. | |
| 1868 | Sep 22 | Guelph Maple Leafs (2nd nine) | Acton Hunkidoras | 113-13 | Acton | GM | |
| 1868 | Sep 23 | Hamilton Stars | St. Catharines Mechanics | 43-33 | See HS 68Sep19, NYC 68Nov21. HS names Frontiers, not Mechanics. HT has score 48-38. | SCEJ | |
| 1868 | Sep 24 | Hamilton Stars | Woodstock Mutuals | 59-13 | Hamilton | See HS 68Sep19, NYC 68Nov21. HT gives score 52-13. | |
| 1868 | Sep 26 | Drummondville Cataracts | Fonthill Fonthills | 36-20 | Fonthill | SCEJ | |
| 1868 | Sep 29 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Victorias | Previewed GH 68Sep22. | |||
| 1868 | Oct 03 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Elora | 129-8 | Guelph | GM | |
| 1868 | Oct 10 | Newcastle Beavers | Bowmanville Live Oaks | 51-41 | Newcastle | G&M 68Oct12. | |
| 1869 | May 01 | Victoria | Collegiate School | 81-34 | Victoria | VC 69May02. | |
| 1869 | May 08 | Victoria Olympic | Collegiate Nine | 81-45 | Victoria | VC 69May08. | |
| 1869 | May 13 | St. Catharines Frontier (2nd nine) | St. Davids Maple Leafs | 35-24 | St. Davids | SCEJ | |
| 1869 | May 21 | Hamilton Golden Leaf | Hamilton Star | 55-44 | Hamilton | See G&M 69May27. HS 69May22 has a 39-33 score. | |
| 1869 | May 24 | Dundas Independents | Hamilton Star | 95-23 | Hamilton | “For a silver cup” (G&M 69May27). Score given in HS 69May25. | |
| 1869 | May 24 | Tillsonburg | Ingersoll Victorias | +14 | Ingersoll | IC 69May27 (previewed IC 69May20). | |
| 1869 | May 29 | Newcastle Beavers (smokers) | Newcastle Beavers (non-smokers) | 45-39 | Newcastle | G&M 69May31. | |
| 1869 | Jun 05 | Burlington | O.K.s | 65-14 | HS 69Jun09. | ||
| 1869 | Jun 08 | Newcastle Beavers (non-smokers) | Newcastle Beavers (smokers) | 49-47 | Newcastle | G&M 69Jun09. | |
| 1869 | Jun 09 | St. Catharines Frontier | Drummondville Cataracts | 35-25 | Drummondville | SCEJ | |
| 1869 | Jun 12 | St. Thomas Erie | Strathroy Excelsiors | 87-50 | Strathroy | STWD | |
| 1869 | Jun 12 | St. Lawrence BBC | Montreal BBC | 44-23 | Montreal | Possibly earliest game played in Montreal (2 weeks before Protoball entry). MES 69Jun14. | |
| 1869 | Jun 17 | Guelph Maple Leafs (smokers) | Guelph Maple Leafs (non-smokers) | 37-27 | Guelph | See GM 69Jun18. | |
| 1869 | Jun 18 | Woodstock Atlantic Juniors | Picked Nine | 28-15 | Woodstock | G&M 69Jun19. | |
| 1869 | Jun 22 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Woodstock Atlantic Juniors | 59-25 | Woodstock | 5 innings. See G&M 69Jun23. | |
| 1869 | Jun 24 | Newcastle Beavers | Port Hope New Dominion | 63-34 | Port Hope | G&M | |
| 1869 | Jun 25 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Aberfoyle | 66-44 | Guelph | See GM 69Jun26. | |
| 1869 | Jun 26 | Montreal BBC | Grand Duchess BBC | 32-22 | Montreal | Protoball entry. 6 innings, at the old cricket ground. MES 69Jun28. | |
| 1869 | Jun 28 | Woodstock Atlantic Juniors | Woodstock Young Canadians | 25-24 | Woodstock | Mentioned in GM 69Jun29, G&M. | |
| 1869 | Jun 29 | Aberfoyle | Flamboro Albertown | 41-21 | Aberfoyle | GEM | |
| 1869 | Jun 29 | St. Catharines Frontier (2nd nine) | St. Catharines Young Mechanics (2nd nine) | +1 | St. Catharines | SCEJ | |
| 1869 | Jun 30 | St. Catharines Frontier | London Tigers | 91-40 | Woodstock | Woodstock tournament. See G&M 69Jul03. | LFP, SCEJ |
| 1869 | Jun 30 | St. Lawrence BBC | Bradley BBC | Montreal | St. Catherine St. grounds. MES 69Jun29. | ||
| 1869 | Jul 01 | Woodstock Atlantic Juniors | St. Thomas Eries | 32-21 | Woodstock | Woodstock tournament. Mentioned in LFP 69Jul03, SCEJ, STWD. | |
| 1869 | Jul 01 | Ingersoll Victorias | London Tecumsehs | 67-56 | Woodstock | Woodstock tournament. SCEJ. | LFP |
| 1869 | Jul 01 | Buffalo Niagaras | Dundas Independents | 49-13 | Dundas | See G&M 69Jul03. Score given in HS 69Jul03. | |
| 1869 | Jul 01 | Tillsonburg | Lyndoch | 99-17 | Tillsonburg | 6 innings. Dominion Day. | TO |
| 1869 | Jul 01 | St. Davids Unions | St. Catharines Young Mechanics | 70-69 | St. Catharines? | SCEJ | |
| 1869 | Jul 02 | Hamilton Gold Leaf | Hamilton Ontarios | 40-13 | Hamilton | HS 69Jul03. | HS |
| 1869 | Jul 02 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Woodstock Young Canadians | 57-38 | Woodstock | Woodstock tournament. Mentioned in GM 69Jul03, and in LFP 69Jul03 (21-run margin). See also G&M 69Jul03. | |
| 1869 | Jul 02 | St. Thomas Eries | London Tigers | 48-7 | Woodstock | Woodstock tournament. 3 innings, for Silver Goblet 3rd prize. See G&M 69Jul03, STWD. | |
| 1869 | Jul 02 | London Tigers | St. Thomas Eries | ? | Woodstock | Woodstock tournament. Mentioned in LFP 69Jul03. Withdrawn by mutual consent after 3 innings, Eries winning. | |
| 1869 | Jul 02 | Woodstock Atlantics | St. Catharines Frontier | 41-22 | Woodstock | Woodstock tournament. See G&M 69Jul03, SCEJ. | |
| 1869 | Jul 03 | Ingersoll Victorias | Guelph Maple Leafs | 45-34 | Woodstock | Woodstock tournament first prize. Previewed G&M 69Jul03. Guelph wins 2nd prize tea set; see GM 69Jul05. | |
| 1869 | Jul 12 | Burlington | Athletic | +54 | Hamilton? | HS 69Jul14. | |
| 1869 | Jul 16 | St. Catharines Frontier | St. Catharines Young Mechanics | +4 or 5 | St. Catharines | SCEJ | |
| 1869 | Jul 23 | Dundas Independents | Guelph Maple Leafs | 40-28 | Dundas | HS 69Jul24, G&M. | |
| 1869 | Jul 24 | Victoria Olympic | Dominion Club | 71-40 | Victoria | VC | |
| 1869 | Jul 26 | Brantford Brants (1st nine) | Brantford Brants (2nd nine) | 67-47 | Brantford | 8 innings; 4 hours. | BWE |
| 1869 | Jul 28 | St. Lawrence BBC | Montreal BBC | 111-30 | Montreal | At the Lacrosse Grounds. MG 69Jul29, MES 69Jul29. | |
| 1869 | Jul 29 | Dundas Independents | London Tecumsehs | 43-18 | London | See NYC 69Aug14, HS 69Jul30, G&M. | LFP |
| 1869 | Jul 29 | London Tigers | St. Marys Young Atlantics | 51-24 | London | NYC 69Aug14 gives 21-run margin. | LFP |
| 1869 | Jul 30 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Dundas Independents | 30-29 | Woodstock | 4 hours. See NYC 69Aug14, G&M. | |
| 1869 | Aug 04 (or Aug 11) | London Tecumsehs second nine | St. Marys Young Atlantics | 76-37 | St. Marys | LFP | |
| 1869 | Aug 05 | Oswego Ontarios | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 23-21 | Oswego | HS 69Aug07. | HS |
| 1869 | Aug 05 | Toronto Union | Hamilton Beavers | 110-42 | Toronto | G&M | |
| 1869 | Aug 06 | St. Thomas Stars | London O.K.s | 68-64 | London | 11 innings. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 06 | Waterford Beavers | Brantford Brants | 43-35 | Brantford | BWE | |
| 1869 | Aug 07 | Simcoe Star | Lyndoch | 54-37 | Lyndoch | PDND | |
| 1869 | Aug 09 | Rouses’ Point | Montreal Base Ball Club | 43-31 | ODC 69Aug10. Rouses’ Point is a village in New York state near the Quebec border. | ||
| 1869 | Aug 10 | Woodstock Young Canadians | St. Catharines Stars | 40-37 | St. Catharines | ||
| 1869 | Aug 11 | St. Catharines Frontier | Woodstock Atlantics | 59-49 | St. Catharines | SCEJ | |
| 1869 | Aug 11 | London Tecumsehs | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 70-43 | Hamilton | LFP, HS | |
| 1869 | Aug 11 | London Eagle BBC | Lincoln Club | 59-26 | London | “Colored” Club. See LFP 69Aug13. | |
| 1869 | Aug 13 | St. Catharines Star | Hamilton Nonpareils | 22-22 | St. Catharines | 1 inning. HS 69Aug16. | |
| 1869 | Aug 13 | Brantford Brants | Brantford Washington Club | 48-38 | Brantford | BWE | |
| 1869 | Aug 14 | Tecumseh | Enterprise | 51-15 | Hamilton? | HS 69Aug17. | |
| 1869 | Aug 16 | London Wide Awakes | London Colored Club | 26-10 | London | “Colored” Club. See LFP 69Aug17. | |
| 1869 | Aug 19 | Hook and Ladder Company | Steamer Company | +16 | London | Fire Brigade Teams. See LFP 69Aug20. | |
| 1869 | Aug 20 | Brooklyn Eckfords | Woodstock Young Canadians | 29-16 | Buffalo | 8 innings. BC 69Aug21 | NYC |
| 1869 | Aug 20 | Brantford Brants | Waterford Beavers | 59-53 | Waterford | BWE | BWE |
| 1869 | Aug 20 | Brantford Washington Club | Paris | ++ | Brantford? | BWE. Played on grounds near residence of Hon. E.B. Wood. Brantford “whipped the Paris boys badly, so much so, that we withhold the score.” | |
| 1869 | Aug 21 | St. John Crescent | Montreal BBC | +11 | Montreal | At Montreal Lacrosse Grounds. St. John is Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu. MH 69Aug20, MH 69Aug23. | |
| 1869 | Aug 23 | London Morning Stars | London Wide Awakes | 25-24 | London | Tournament. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 23 | Lyndoch | Simcoe | +9 | Simcoe | G&M | |
| 1869 | Aug 24 | St. Thomas Stars | Strathroy Albions | 67-24 | London | Tournament. 8 innings. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 24 | St. Marys Beavers | London O.K.s | 79-68 | London | Tournament. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 24 | Woodstock Atlantics | St. Thomas Eries | 52-22 | London | Tournament. 6 innings. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 25 | Hamilton Excelsiors | Hamilton Ontarios | 38-33 | London | Tournament. HS 69Aug26. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 25 | St. Marys Beavers | London Morning Stars | 46-23 | London | Tournament. See LFP 69Aug26. | |
| 1869 | Aug 25 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Ingersoll Victorias | 76-32 | London | Tournament. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 25 | London Tigers | Strathroy Excelsiors | 61-25 | London | Tournament. HS 69Aug28. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 26 | Woodstock Atlantics | London Tigers | 63-20 | London | Tournament. 7 innings. HS 69Aug28. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 26 | St. Marys Beavers | St. Thomas Stars | 55-43 | London | Tournament. St. Marys wins 3rd class. HS 69Aug28. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 26 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Woodstock Young Canadians | 30-16 | London | Tournament. 8 innings. Guelph wins 1st class. HS 69Aug28, G&M. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 26 | Buffalo Niagaras | Dundas Independents | 49-20 | Buffalo | HS 69Aug28. | |
| 1869 | Aug 27 | Detroit Rialtos | London Goodwills | 33-20 | London | Tournament. 2 “colored” teams, a first in Canada. See LFP 69Aug28, LFP 69Sep01. Discussion. | |
| 1869 | Aug 27 | Woodstock Atlantics | Hamilton Excelsiors | 70-19 | London | Tournament. Woodstock wins 2nd class. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 27 | London Morning Stars | St. Thomas Stars | 58-34 | London | Tournament. 6 innings. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 28 | Hamilton Excelsiors | London Tecumsehs 2nd nine | 59-43 | London | Tournament. | LFP |
| 1869 | Aug 28 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Ingersoll Victorias | 70-24 | London | Tournament. 7 innings. | LFP |
| 1869 | Sep 04 | Crescent of St. John | Montreal St. Lawrence | 69-37 | ? | First interprovincial match? NYC 69Sep25. | |
| 1869 | Sep 15 | Queen City of Buffalo | Ontarios of Hamilton | 20-18 | Hamilton | 6 innings. Shuttleworth umpire. HS 69Sep16. | NYC, HS |
| 1869 | Sep 17 | London Tecumsehs (Bachelors) | London Tecumsehs (Benedicts) | 55-39 | London | 6 innings. | LFP |
| 1869 | Sep 24 | Guelph Maple Leafs | London Tecumsehs | 43-20 | London | Silver Ball match. Goldie hits 3 HR. HS 69Sep25. | NYC, LFP |
| 1869 | Oct 01 | London Tecumseh Benedicts | London Tecumseh Bachelors | 37-34 | London | 7 1/2 innings. See LFP 69Oct02. | |
| 1869 | Mid-Oct | Newcastle Beavers | Cobourg Victoria | 41-28 | Newcastle | OT 69Oct22. | |
| 1870 | May 18 | Rockford Forest City | Nine composed of Hamilton Maple Leafs and Dundas Independents | 65-3 | Hamilton | See BC 70May20. | HS |
| 1870 | May 24 | Red Stockings | Commercial College Club | 27-25 | London | LFP | |
| 1870 | May 24 | London Young Mechanics | London O.K.s | 38-36 | London | LFP | |
| 1870 | May 24 | London Morning Stars | St. Thomas picked nine | 29-20 | St. Thomas | LFP | |
| 1870 | May 25 | St. Catharines Frontiers | Hamilton Mutuals | 38-35 | Hamilton | Union Championship | HWT |
| 1870 | Jun 01 | London Tecumsehs | London Morning Stars | 43-21 | London | LFP | |
| 1870 | Jun 01 | Hamilton OK | Hamilton Tecumseh | 49-38 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1870 | Jun 04 | London O.K.s | London Hellmuth College Club | London | See LFP 70Jun06. | ||
| 1870 | Jun 11 | Port Dover | Jarvis | 46-45 | Jarvis | 6 1/2 innings; rain. | PDND |
| 1870 | Jun 13 | St. Marys Beavers | London Morning Stars | 33-28 | London | LFP | |
| 1870 | Jun 14 | Hamilton Mechanics | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 88-55 | Hamilton | HWT | |
| 1870 | Jun 14 | Brampton Mechanics | Brampton Maple Leafs | +20 | Brampton | G&M 70Jun15. | |
| 1870 | Jun 16 | Hamilton Mutuals | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 9-0 | Hamilton | Forfeit; score after 10 was 24-24. HS | NYC |
| 1870 | Jun 17 | London O.K.s | London Young Mechanics | 27-25 | London | LFP | |
| 1870 | Jun 29 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Aberfoyle | 64-23 | Guelph | Silver Ball match. NYC gives date as Jun24. | NYC, GA |
| 1870 | Jul 01 | Woodstock Young Canadians | London Tecumsehs | 62-28 | London | See LFP 70Jul04. | |
| 1870 | Jul 01 | London Young Mechanics | St. Marys Beavers | +7 | St. Marys | 5 innings. See LFP 70Jul04. | |
| 1870 | Jul 01 | London Morning Stars | Strathroy Excelsiors | +24 | Strathroy | See LFP 70Jul04. | |
| 1870 | Jul 08 | Seaforth Union | Ainleyville Maitland | 44-33 | Ainleyville | MA | |
| 1870 | Jul 13 | London Tecumsehs | Woodstock Young Canadians | 53-46 | Woodstock | LFP | |
| 1870 | Jul 15 | Acton Pastimes | Milton Sycamores | 62-18? | Acton | GEM | |
| 1870 | Jul 15 | Acton Pastimes | Brampton Mechanics | 18-1? | Acton | GEM | |
| 1870 | Jul 18 | London Tecumsehs | London Cricket Club | 35-14 | London | 6 innings. See LFP 70Jul19. | |
| 1870 | Jul 19 | London Morning Stars | London O.K.s | 30-14 | London | LFP | |
| 1870 | Jul 19 | Toronto Dauntless | Hamilton Ontarios | 50-33 | Toronto | NYC | |
| 1870 | Jul 20 | Simcoe | Waterford | 56-37 | Simcoe | PDND | |
| 1870 | Jul 22 | Hamilton Mutuals | St. Catharines Frontier | ? | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1870 | Jul 22 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Dundas Independents | 24-22 | Guelph | HS. 10 innings. Silver Ball match. GA has game date discrepancy. HS has score 26-24. | NYC, GA |
| 1870 | Jul 23 | London Twilights | London Unions | 44-43 | London | See LFP 70Jul25. | |
| 1870 | Jul 30 | Ingersoll | Tillsonburg | 47-45 | Tillsonburg | TO | |
| 1870 | Jul 30 | Acton Pastimes | Brampton Mechanics | 47-41 | Brampton | HS | |
| 1870 | Aug 01 | Ainleyville Maitland | Seaforth Union | +22 | Seaforth | MA 70Aug05. | |
| 1870 | Aug 02 | London Young Eckfords | Strathroy Excelsiors | 69-28 | Strathroy | See LFP 70Aug03. | |
| 1870 | Aug 05 | London O.K.s | St. Thomas Eurekas | 74-48 | London | LFP | |
| 1870 | Aug 05 | Mount Forest | Fergus | +15 | Fergus | 8 innings (rain). G&M 70Aug06. | |
| 1870 | Aug 05 | Waterford Beaver Club | Simcoe Star Club | 41-21 | Simcoe | PDND | |
| 1870 | Aug 08 | Toronto Dauntless | Hamilton Ontarios | 31-27 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1870 | Aug 11 | London Young Eckfords | London Tigers | 54-35 | London | See LFP 70Aug12. | |
| 1870 | Aug 12 | Wroxeter | Bluevale | OT 70Aug19. | |||
| 1870 | Aug 12 | Hamilton Mutuals | Hamilton Maple Leafs | ? | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1870 | Aug 13 | Acton | Milton | Milton | OT 70Aug19. | ||
| 1870 | Aug 13 | Lyndoch | Tillsonburg | 46-38 | Lyndoch | TO 70Aug18. | TO |
| 1870 | Aug 16 | Hespeler Stars | Waterloo Prince Arthurs | 55-31 | Hespeler | GA | |
| 1870 | Aug 16 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Woodstock Young Canadians | 34-13 | Guelph | Silver Ball match | NYC, GA |
| 1870 | Aug 18 | Fergus | Mount Forest | +9 | Mount Forest | G&M 70Aug19. | |
| 1870 | Aug 19 | Dundas Independents | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 49-21 | Dundas | Winners called Dundee Independents | NYC, HS |
| 1870 | Aug 20 | Port Dover | Jarvis | 25-23 | ? | “Too much betting.” | PDND |
| 1870 | Aug 22 | Knickerbockers of New York | Montreal Base Ball Club | 54-32 | Montreal | MG 70Aug23. On grounds of the Montreal Lacrosse Club on Sherbrooke St. | |
| 1870 | Aug 22 | Hamilton Mutuals | Paris | Paris | HS. Mutuals tour; was game played? | ||
| 1870 | Aug 22 | Dundas Enterprise | Hamilton Atlantics | 34-33 | Dundas | HS | |
| 1870 | Aug 23 | London Tecumsehs | Hamilton Mutuals | 47-14 | London | Mutuals tour. | LFP |
| 1870 | Aug 24 | Hamilton Mutuals | London O.K.s | 10-9 | London | 3 innings; thunderstorm. Mutuals tour. See LFP 70Aug25. | |
| 1870 | Aug 25 | Hamilton Mutuals | Ingersoll | Ingersoll | HS. Mutuals tour; was game played? | ||
| 1870 | Aug 25 | London Morning Stars | St. Catharines Frontiers | 58-16 | St. Catharines | LFP | |
| 1870 | Aug 26 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Hamilton Mutuals | 30-9 | Woodstock | HS. Mutuals tour. | |
| 1870 | Aug 27 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Hamilton Mutual | 79-9 | Guelph | HS. Mutuals tour. | |
| 1870 | Sep 01 | Woodstock Star | Ingersoll Young Drovers | 33-24 | Woodstock | HS. G&M 70Sep02. G&M gives score as 55-24. | |
| 1870 | Sep 05 | Dundas Independents | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 44-30 | Hamilton | HS | |
| 1870 | Sep 09 | Coaticook (PQ) | Nonpareil Club of Stanstead (PQ) | +2 | Stanstead | OIS 70Sep13. | |
| 1870 | Sep 10 | Lyndoch | Port Dover | 26-19 | Simcoe | PDND | |
| 1870 | Sep 12 | Hamilton Maple Leafs | St. Catharines Pickwick | 49-18 | Hamilton | 6 innings. | HS |
| 1870 | Sep 13 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Rochester Flour City | 45-17 | Rochester | NYC | |
| 1870 | Sep 14 | Syracuse Eckfords | Guelph Maple Leafs | 21-15 | Syracuse | Mentioned in SDC 70Sep15 (Maple Leaves!). | SDS |
| 1870 | Sep 15 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Oswego Ontario | 42-12 | Oswego | Oswego Press. | |
| 1870 | Sep 27 | London Tecumsehs | Cleveland Grove City | 29-18 | London | LFP | |
| 1870 | Sep 29 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 24-21 | Guelph | HS. Silver Ball. | |
| 1870 | Oct 03 | Rochester Flour City | Hamilton Mutuals | 42-8 | Hamilton | LFP. Rain delay after 2nd inning; game called after 8 innings. Flour City tour. | |
| 1870 | Oct 04 | Rochester Flour City | Dundas Independents | 25-12 | Dundas | HS. 7 innings (darkness). Flour City tour. | |
| 1870 | Oct 05 | Rochester Flour City | London Tecumsehs | 22-14 | London | HS. Flour City tour. | LFP |
| 1870 | Oct 06 | Woodstock Young Canadians | Rochester Flour City | 45-34 | Woodstock | HS. Flour City tour. | |
| 1870 | Oct 07 | Guelph Maple Leafs | Rochester Flour City | 47-8 | Guelph | HS. Flour City tour. | |
| 1870 | Oct 09 | Rochester Flour City | Hamilton Maple Leafs | 23-22 | Hamilton | Flour City tour. | HS |
| 1870 | Oct 15 | Seaforth Coopers | Waterloo | Seaforth | MA 70Oct21. |